Week 3 Matchups + Wheel of Shame!
Week 3 matchup previews and start/sit decisions on today’s fantasy football podcast! Reactions to Thursday Night Football, injury updates, and more. Plus, Jason spins the Wheel of Shame during the Fantasy Faceoff! Get fantasy football lineup advice for your Week 3 matchups! Manage your redraft, keeper, and dynasty fantasy football teams with the #1 fantasy football podcast. — Fantasy Football Podcast for September 20th, 2024.
Connect with the show:
- Subscribe on YouTube
- Visit us on the Web
- Support the Show
- Follow on X
- Follow on Instagram
- Join our Discord
Check out today’s sponsors:
News & Notes presented by USAA. Visit https://www.USAA.com/Insurance
Fantasy Forecast presented by DraftKings Sportsbook
Summary:
Matchup Insights and Player Performance 00:55
- The hosts discuss the implications of Aaron Rodgers‘ performance in the recent game, noting that while he looked good overall, he also displayed signs of rust. They mention that he was able to connect on various types of passes, indicating potential for improvement moving forward.
- Garrett Wilson‘s performance is scrutinized, specifically addressing the concerns following his limited yardage despite scoring a touchdown. The hosts deliberate whether this is a “sell high” opportunity for fantasy managers. They point out that while defenses are focusing on Wilson, he could still develop into a top receiver if he builds chemistry with Rodgers.
- The discussion also includes comparisons with other quarterbacks, emphasizing that defenses are now more adept at neutralizing star wide receivers, which adds to the complexity of Wilson’s role in the offense.
“The question of the game is whether this was a good performance because he scored a touchdown, or a bad game due to only a few total yards.”
Running Back Analysis and Team Performance 07:48
- The hosts analyze the poor performance of the New England Patriots‘ running back, Rhamondre Stevenson, who had a disappointing outing amidst an already struggling offensive line. They express concerns over the team’s ability to maintain strong production from key players due to injuries.
- The conversation shifts to Breece Hall and his emerging value alongside rookie running back Brayan Allen. Despite Hall’s solid performance, the hosts highlight that Allen is becoming a legitimate part of the offense, which may impact Hall’s potential fantasy output.
- They speculate about the sharing of opportunities between Hall and Allen but also express confidence that Hall will remain a viable fantasy option moving forward.
“Breece is going to be very good for fantasy, but it does cap a legendary type of season.”
Impressions of Young Talents and Draft Evaluations 10:25
- The discussion highlights the growing recognition of younger players in the NFL, particularly focusing on a 20-year-old running back who gained traction during the draft process. The sentiments shared indicate the unnecessary pressure players face during combines, where their performance is assessed in non-game-like conditions.
- Players like Dalvin Cook and Kareem Hunt are mentioned as examples of individuals who may not have excelled at combines but became standouts on the field. There is a call to shift the combine evaluations to represent the actual playing conditions by incorporating pads into the 40-yard dash tests.
- The speaker emphasizes the importance of in-game performance over combine metrics, pointing out the success of players who were undervalued because of how they performed outside of actual football games.
“How about the ratio between the pads on and pads off 40? Can we do something that represents playing football?”
Assessing Player Performance and Team Strategies 12:10
- As the conversation shifts, the focus turns to the performance of the Jets and how they manage their players, particularly the running back, Bree Hall. The strategy of monitoring player health to maximize efficiency demonstrates an understanding of the team’s dynamics and the physical demands on players in the league.
- The dialogue touches on specific plays that showcase the player’s strength and resilience, reinforcing that effective running backs can maintain composure even under intense pressure from defenders. A lighthearted moment refers to a player’s big game with humorous imagery, adding levity to the analysis of performance.
“It looks like, by far, the best… he had a defender just clobber him in the backfield and he doesn’t move.”
Fantasy Football Insights and Player Updates 12:30
- The conversation transitions to fantasy football news, with a focus on injuries and practice statuses impacting player availability. The hosts provide updates on various players, including Cam Akers and Joe Mixon, whom their absence elevates into potential starters for their teams.
- The hosts exchange thoughts on the matchups for the upcoming week, weighing the risks and advantages of starting players under uncertain conditions, highlighting a strategic aspect to fantasy football management.
- As injuries affect team lineups, the decision-making process for fantasy managers becomes crucial, and the dialogue illustrates the complexity of these choices.
“If both guys missed, Cam Akers is an okay start; he’s looked good in the system.”
Fantasy Football Insights: Running Back Decisions 20:50
- Rashad White has had a challenging start to the season, with the lowest receiving total in 20 games causing uncertainty about his performance. If he is active for a game, he should be played over other running backs like Carson Steele or Cam Akers, regardless of how they are performing. If White is inactive, Bucky Irving has shown enough potential to be a viable pickup.
- When considering matchups, Rashad White remains a better choice than J.K. Dobbins against the Steelers, especially with a high-scoring game expected.
- A focus on the Raiders demonstrates a potential opportunity for fantasy players, with various matchups in the next weeks allowing for strategic pickups.
“I’m basically playing whichever running back is active in this game.”
Carolina Panthers – Opportunities and Challenges 21:33
- The Carolina Panthers, currently winless, face the Las Vegas Raiders. The matchup’s odds suggest a struggle for Carolina, especially with Andy Dalton starting. The Panthers have significant challenges ahead against competitive teams.
- Notable players from the Raiders, including Davante Adams and Brock Bowers, are recommended as solid starters this week, while others such as Jacobi Meyers might need to be reconsidered due to underperformance.
“Andy Dalton begins again in Carolina.”
Wide Receiver Lineup Decisions 25:11
- Miami’s approach to playing against the Seattle Seahawks is analyzed, particularly focusing on players like Skyler Thompson and Gino Smith. The utilization of players such as Jaxson Smith-Njigba (JSN) suggests a promising role this week, making him a flex option for fantasy owners.
- The discussion extends to the rankings of other wide receivers, such as Amari Cooper and Tank Dell, with it being recommended to favor JSN over them based on recent performance statistics.
“You have to put JSN in your lineup.”
Fantasy Football Matchup Insights 30:20
- The matchup between the Baltimore Ravens and the Dallas Cowboys is anticipated to be engaging, especially for fantasy football players. Dak Prescott‘s passing yard line is set at 253 yards, and there’s potential for a fun game even if one team falls behind. Importance is placed on key players like CeeDee Lamb and Dak Prescott getting involved in the offense.
- Early season performances from Baltimore suggest that they will score points, which can provide opportunities for players like Mark Andrews, who had a strong week and is expected to be heavily utilized against the Dallas defense, known to be moderate against tight ends. The Dallas running back situation remains uncertain, with many players not yet deemed reliable for starting positions.
“If CeeDee’s healthy, they’ll score points.”
Analysis of the Rams vs. 49ers Game 33:12
- The San Francisco 49ers are set to face the Los Angeles Rams, with an over/under of 43.5 points. Despite the Rams struggling with injuries, particularly at wide receiver, including the absence of Cooper Kupp, there is an expectation for Jordan Mason on the 49ers as he is projected to have a high rushing yard line due to circumstances in the game.
- The Rams are having a rough time managing staff protection for quarterback Matthew Stafford, which may lead to a reliance on the run game. Fantasy players need to be cautious, with limited options to explore among the Rams’ wide receivers, focusing instead on the likely standout like DeMarcus Robinson.
“If the Rams can’t protect Matthew Stafford, you’re just going to have them running down the throats of the Rams over and over.”
Detroit Lions vs. Arizona Cardinals Expectations 36:56
- The Lions and Cardinals matchup presents an exciting possibility with an over under of 51.5 points. Historically, Detroit’s defense has been easier to throw against than to run on, suggesting a fruitful game for wide receivers. The emergence of players like Greg Dortch for spot starting in fantasy lineups is encouraged, especially due to Detroit’s susceptibility in the slot.
- Key players to watch include Marvin Harrison, Tyler, and James Conner, the latter being valuable though his performance may fluctuate. There’s an expectation for Jared Goff‘s performance to improve in this game, driven partly by the Cardinals’ struggling defense against vertical threats.
“You can and must throw on them; it is a wonderfully predictable thing for Fantasy Football.”
Analyzing Player Performance and Matchups 40:05
- Jared Goff‘s performance is regarded as adequate but not exceptional. He is preferred over players like Anthony Richardson, Brock Purdy, and Geno Smith on fantasy teams.
- The discussion shifts to tight end Trey McBride, who is considered to have underwhelmed despite a touchdown. The expectation for tight ends is quite low, and McBride’s performance does not quite meet the high standards that fantasy owners seek.
- Expectations are set for the involvement of different players each week, with Ben Johnson noting, “Last week it was Amon-Ra St. Brown, this week it’s LaPorta, next week it’s going to be somebody else.”
- There appears to be apprehension regarding the consistency and predictability of player performances, especially with the presence of multiple talented options on the team.
“Last week it was Amon-Ra St. Brown, this week it’s LaPorta, next week it’s going to be somebody else.”
Upcoming Double Header Insights 41:51
- Anticipation builds around the upcoming double Monday Night Football games, with a notable matchup between the Chiefs and Falcons.
- The Chiefs are favored by three points, indicating expected tight competition. Observations from previous games suggest that the Chiefs have exhibited some weaknesses, especially on offense, which might impact their performance against the Falcons.
- Injuries and disruptions in team efficiency are highlighted as significant factors that could affect the Chiefs’ ability to maintain their offensive prowess, which normally relies heavily on running the football.
“The Chiefs have looked like last week’s performance against Cincinnati showed some cracks in the offense.”
Fantasy Player Considerations for Week Three 43:50
- Patrick Mahomes remains a key player, although there’s concern about the overall offensive fluidity of the Chiefs as they adjust to player losses and performance uncertainty.
- The Falcons are highlighted as a team to watch, with their defense showing signs of strength in previous matchups.
- Player performances are scrutinized, with specific mention of Drake London and Kyle Pitts as players facing inconsistent target shares. London’s historical performance has led to questions about his viability as a fantasy starter compared to other emerging players.
“Drake London has a consistency score reflecting that he is underperforming, making it a challenge for fantasy owners.”
Fantasy Football Insights on Quarterbacks and Matchups 49:32
- The discussion revolves around choosing quarterbacks for fantasy football, with players like Jaden Daniels and Jared Goff being considered over Patrick Mahomes, who has struggled this season. Mahomes has not scored more than 15 fantasy points and only surpassed 17 points once since Halloween of the previous year. Despite his reputation, these numbers highlight a significant decline in his performance.
- There is skepticism about the Jacksonville Jaguars‘ ability to compete with the Buffalo Bills, especially given the Jaguars’ poor performance thus far. The Bills have shown strength both offensively and defensively, making predictions lean heavily in their favor, with a suggested line of Buffalo minus 5.
“Mahomes has not scored 15 fantasy points so far this season. That is insane.”
Performance Analysis of Anthony Richardson and Trevor Lawrence 51:34
- A comparison of completion percentages shows that both Anthony Richardson and Trevor Lawrence are struggling, with Richardson at 49% and Lawrence at 51%. This statistic raises eyebrows, particularly given the high expectations for Lawrence this season. The team is missing key players like Calvin Ridley and appears to be lacking offensive flow.
- As the conversation continues, it is noted that the Cincinnati Bengals are facing the Washington Commanders, with expectations that Joe Burrow will have a standout performance in this game. The analysis points towards a potential bounce-back for Burrow, making him a notable start of the week.
“You wouldn’t be asking that question if the answer was Trevor Lawrence.”
Updates on Players and Recommendations for Fantasy Picks 55:19
- There are updates regarding injured players, with mentions that T Higgins is limited at practice and discussions about whether to stash backups like Mike Giki, hoping to capture the potential of players like Jamar Chase. Giki has shown promise in previous games, leading in team targets but is also dealing with his own injury issues.
- Fantasy managers are encouraged to leverage the opportunities against weak defenses, particularly targeting teams like the Washington Commanders which historically struggle against both quarterbacks and running backs. The recommendation is to start players like Zack Moss due to favorable matchup conditions.
“I’m trying my best to hold out for T Higgins; the matchup is so juicy.”
Fantasy Player Discussion: McLaurin vs. Pittman 59:20
- The conversation begins with a debate on whether fantasy player Terry McLaurin or Michael Pittman Jr. should be in the starting lineup. With recent news impacting Pittman, the consensus is leaning toward avoiding both players due to their struggles. McLaurin had disappointing stats in his first two weeks, making him hard to justify as a starter.
- The speakers express a mutual agreement that many other players have better potential for performance than McLaurin and Pittman, thus making them borderline unplayable at this point in the season.
“I would play a lot of other players over those two.”
Transition to Week Two and Predictions 01:00:10
- As they turn their attention to Week Two, the discussion includes a recap of the previous week’s performance, highlighting the competition among the participants in their fantasy league. One member is leading the pack, while another is set to face the consequences of a poor performance with the ‘Wheel of Shame.’
- The segment emphasizes the competitive nature of fantasy sports and the unpredictability of player performances.
“Week one in the books, Week two in the book.”
Player Lineups and Choices 01:01:50
- The participants share their quarterback choices, indicating that they both selected Derek Carr as their starter for the upcoming week. They highlight the emotional investment in their selections, particularly regarding Carr’s performance.
- The discussion moves into the running back selections, revealing that two of the participants chose the same players, Jordan Mason and Tony Pollard. There’s a mix of light-hearted commentary about last-minute lineup changes, showcasing the fluidity of fantasy preparation.
“What could go wrong emotionally?”
Wide Receivers and Other Positions 01:03:00
- As they delve into their wide receiver choices, there’s a clear strategy of stacking players to maximize potential scoring opportunities based on matchups, including selections like Olave and Smith. The conversation highlights various player statistics and anticipated performances.
- The dialogue continues with their tight end picks and flex options, showcasing the players they expect to perform well in Week Two. Each participant outlines their reasoning for selecting specific players over others.
“I wanted to have a player that I didn’t expect in your lineups.”
Defensive Strategies and Updates 01:05:40
- The participants conclude their lineup discussions with insights into their defensive strategies, focusing on defenses they believe will perform well based on the opponent’s weaknesses.
- They wrap up by sharing that Jordan Love is practicing again, adding context and updates that are relevant to those monitoring player conditions.
“The only quick update I know of is Jordan Love is practicing again.”

