Week 12 Studs & Duds + Wild Weekend Reactions!
Week 12 fantasy football recap on today’s podcast! Andy, Mike, and Jason discuss the best and worst fantasy performances from Week 12. Plus, a deep dive review of rookie QBs so far this season, and Monday Punday! Manage your redraft, keeper, and dynasty fantasy football teams with the #1 fantasy football podcast. — Fantasy Football Podcast for November 25th, 2024.
Connect with the show:
- Subscribe on YouTube
- Visit us on the Web
- Support the Show
- Follow on X
- Follow on Instagram
- Join our Discord
Check out today’s sponsors:
Ready to Roll presented by Nissan. Visit https://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/crossovers-suvs/pathfinder/rock-creek-edition.html
News & Notes presented by USAA. Visit https://USAA.com/Insurance
Summary:
Weekend Reflections and Podcast Dynamics 00:00
“Sometimes coming to work is the break from the weekend.”
- The hosts share their different weekend experiences, with one expressing relief from the typical weekend tasks, indicating that their time together on the podcast acts as a welcomed respite.
- They note that although they usually watch football together, this past weekend was unique as they were all physically apart, reflecting a change from their usual routine.
- Listening to each other’s experiences adds to the excitement as they prepare to dive into discussions about the weekend’s football activities.
Football Highlights and Predictions 02:21
“We have a lot of studs and duds to talk about.”
- The podcast promises an engaging segment discussing standout players and those who underperformed during the week, setting the stage for a lively breakdown.
- There is an anticipation building for the upcoming game, with one host humorously expressing a desire for certain players to perform poorly, showcasing the strategic elements of fantasy football.
- The conversation shifts to humorous team names and puns, highlighting the lighthearted yet competitive environment that often accompanies fantasy leagues.
Rookie Quarterbacks Performance 07:27
“In week 12, three of the top six fantasy quarterbacks happen to be rookies.”
- The hosts examine the impressive performances of rookie quarterbacks, putting their current standings in historical context and discussing how they have excelled in recent weeks.
- References to specific players, such as Jaden Daniels, Caleb Williams, and Bo Nix, illustrate the unpredictable and exciting nature of the current NFL season.
- The rookie quarterbacks’ statistics are compared to legendary past performances, emphasizing the significance of their contributions to their teams and the fantasy leagues.
Rookie Quarterback Performances and Comparisons 10:59
“There’s certainly huge optimism here for most of this rookie class.”
- The discussion focuses on the performances of rookie quarterbacks, particularly Marvin Mims and Caleb Williams. The hosts acknowledge an upward trend in Caleb Williams‘s performance, attributing it to recent changes in the offensive strategy, which has allowed him to showcase his skills more effectively.
- Comparisons are drawn between various rookies, highlighting that while completion percentages are relatively average across the board, notable standouts include Jayden Daniels, who ranks second all-time among rookie quarterbacks with a 68.4% completion rate.
- Specifically, the optimism surrounding Caleb Williams suggests he may evolve into a franchise quarterback over time, contrasting with the struggles of Bryce Young in his rookie season.
Evaluating Drake May and Anthony Richardson 12:20
“Drake May is fine. I think him and Caleb Williams are actually performing at a similar level right now.”
- Drake May’s early games were seen positively, but his performance is tempered by the lack of solid support from his team. He boasts a 65.5% completion rate but is surrounded by less effective players, which greatly impacts his productivity. The humor in the comment about his top target being named “Booty” underscores his challenging situation.
- The conversation shifts to Anthony Richardson, who is still considered a rookie despite having less playing experience. The hosts note inconsistencies in Richardson’s performance, highlighting specific games where his stats were misleading due to factors like penalties.
- Overall, both May and Richardson face tough circumstances that complicate their performances, impacting their potential growth in quarterback roles.
Changing Trends in Rookie Quarterback Success 16:30
“This is certainly breaking the mold seen historically among rookie quarterbacks.”
- The hosts reflect on past rookie quarterback drafts that did not live up to expectations, noting that the current class appears more promising compared to previous years. They discuss how the performances of Sutton and McLaurin are breaking the historical trend where rookie quarterbacks typically failed to elevate their wide receivers’ performance significantly.
- They suggest that while historic data shows rookie quarterbacks had little impact on their wide receivers achieving double-digit touchdowns, the current draft class is altering that narrative, refreshing expectations for future quarterbacks.
Injury Analysis and Fantasy Ramifications 20:25
“When that tackle happened, it looked like it was a hip drop.”
- The hosts discuss an incident involving player Brian Robinson, who faces a potential season-ending injury after a tackle that was described as possibly a hip drop. Concerns arise not just for the hip but also for the knee, as the mechanics of the tackle could lead to severe injury.
- They draw parallels to Joe Mixon‘s similar experience from the past season, where a hip drop tackle resulted in him missing several games. This underlines the severity of such tackles and their impact on player availability for fantasy teams.
Player Updates and Impactful Injuries 21:25
“Austin Ekeler had a brutal concussion. He’s getting the concussion protocol.”
- Recent injuries to notable players like Austin Ekeler and David Montgomery are highlighted, particularly Ekeler’s concussion which will keep him sidelined for the upcoming week. The hosts express concern as fantasy owners will feel the impact of these injuries.
- The conversation shifts to Jeremy McNichols, who presents an opportunity for those looking at potential replacements in fantasy leagues. Additional injuries, including Josh Downs‘ shoulder issue and others, indicate a tumultuous week for player health.
Aaron Rodgers Situation and Fantasy Predictions 25:03
“The news is spreading that Aaron Rodgers does not want to play for the Jets anymore.”
- The hosts delve into the situation surrounding Aaron Rodgers, noting he may be sidelined or even benched due to ongoing injuries, which has implications for his future and the Jets organization. Discussions highlight how this news might affect players like Garrett Wilson and Davante Adams.
- Comparisons are made between Rodgers and Brett Favre, exploring the potential consequences for the NFL landscape if Rodgers moves on from the Jets. Their remarks hint at a crisis for the Jets as they navigate the fallout from Rodgers’ refusal to continue.
Future Prospects and Team Dynamics 28:51
“There’s no place that Aaron Rodgers can go and win.”
- The hosts express skepticism about Rodgers’ chances of thriving on another team, citing the lack of viable options and questioning whether any team will be willing to invest in his future. They reflect on his performance and the support he’s received yet still failed to capitalize on opportunities.
- Overall, they contemplate the future of both Rodgers and the teams that might consider him, suggesting a significant shift in dynamics stemming from his current situation.
Quarterback Performance Analysis 29:31
“Baker Mayfield had a rushing touchdown but did not throw a passing touchdown despite an impressive yardage total.”
- This segment highlights the performance of several quarterbacks, notably Tua Tagovailoa, Caleb Williams, and Sam Darnold, followed by an interesting discussion about Patrick Mahomes.
- Mahomes, who previously struggled to score fantasy points, is mentioned as making a comeback, finishing strong in recent weeks.
- Factors contributing to Mahomes’ resurgence include his star-studded receiving options like DeAndre Hopkins, JuJu Smith-Schuster, and Travis Kelce, as well as a less dominant Chiefs defense that forces him to take more action on the field.
- Baker Mayfield‘s game is also dissected; although he threw for 294 yards and scored a rushing touchdown, the absence of passing touchdowns amid a commanding victory raised questions about the team’s game strategy.
Running Back Highlights 33:24
“Saquon Barkley is now entering the MVP conversation among running backs with his incredible yardage and multiple touchdowns.”
- The analysis transitions to standout running backs, starting with Saquon Barkley‘s notable recent performance, where he accumulated 200 yards and two touchdowns.
- Josh Jacobs and Bucky Irving are also highlighted for their impressive outings, with Irving unexpectedly unseating Rashad White in workload while proving effective in both the running and passing game.
- Jameer Gibbs is showcased after a strong performance in place of the injured David Montgomery, where he capitalizes on increased opportunities and showcases his potential as a top fantasy asset.
- Devon Achane’s performance is debated, focusing on his scoring capacity despite not reaching high yardage totals, indicating the complexity of defining a “stud” player solely based on yardage.
Wide Receiver Performances 38:41
“Jordan Addison was the top performer among wide receivers this week, demonstrating the value of involving top players in the offense.”
- The discussion wraps up with the wide receiver performances, where Jordan Addison claims the top spot among fantasy performers alongside Cortland Sutton and Jaylen Waddle.
- DJ Moore is also acknowledged for his recent involvement, reinforcing the strategy of ensuring that key offensive players receive touch opportunities.
- The commentary suggests that emphasizing touches for good players can markedly enhance a team’s offensive effectiveness, underlining the importance of strategic player involvement.
DJ Moore‘s Performance Analysis 39:09
“In terms of targets and receptions, DJ Moore was actually identical to last week. Seven targets, seven receptions.”
- DJ Moore continues to show consistency in his performance, mirroring his previous week with the same number of targets and receptions. This reliability is crucial for his team’s offensive strategy, allowing them to leverage his skills effectively.
- Despite his identical numbers from last week, Moore’s role as the wide receiver three signifies a shift in team dynamics, suggesting an increased focus on other offensive players.
The Exciting Use of Screens Post-Firing 39:21
“The way that they are using him in the screen game post Shane Waldron’s firing is so exciting.”
- Following Shane Waldron’s departure, there has been a noticeable shift in how teams utilize their players in screen plays. This strategy is particularly beneficial for players like DJ Moore, who have the agility and speed to convert short gains into big plays.
- By effectively employing screens, the team maximizes the opportunity for Moore to score, whether from short yardage or long distances, enhancing his playmaking potential.
High-Performing Wide Receivers 40:03
“Carl and Son continues his onslaught—10 more targets, caught 80% of them.”
- The current trend showcases high-performing wide receivers, with players like Carl and Son demonstrating exceptional catch percentages and target shares.
- Consistent performances, such as receiving two touchdowns, underline the dynamic nature of today’s wide receiver position, contributing significantly to fantasy football scoring and overall team performance.
The Emergence of JSN and His Developments 40:31
“JSN has been on fire. He’s been a wide receiver one for three straight weeks.”
- JSN’s rise in performance has been remarkable, solidifying his status as a top-wide receiver for three consecutive weeks. This upward trajectory indicates his growing role in the team’s offense, likely defining him as a key player for the remainder of the season.
- His impressive and consistent scoring is partly driven by a high volume of passing attempts, emphasizing the importance of a productive passing game for fantasy expectations.
The Doubt Over Kyler Murray‘s Consistency 45:43
“I’ve never seen him start with a bad first half and finish strong.”
- Kyler Murray‘s inconsistent performance remains a concern for his fantasy owners, as he has a tendency to oscillate between outstanding and poor play. This volatility poses a risk in critical matchups, especially during the fantasy playoffs.
- The complexity of Murray’s game underscores the reality that while he can produce top-tier performances, he can equally deliver subpar results, making him a volatile fantasy quarterback.
The Rise of John NuSmith as a Top Tight End 47:00
“John NuSmith is the number one tight end since week seven.”
- John NuSmith’s emergence as a top tight end highlights a shift in offensive dynamics, as his increased involvement has correlated with the team’s scoring success. His recent performances reflect a newfound ability to contribute significantly to the offense.
- However, there are concerns that his rising prominence may detract from other key players, suggesting a balancing act is necessary for the overall performance of the team.
Performance Analysis on Tight Ends 49:02
“George Kittle‘s so much worse for the offense than Debo.”
- The discussion revolves around the impact of players George Kittle and Debo Samuel on their team’s offensive performance. It is noted that Kittle, despite being an excellent NFL tight end and potentially the best in the league, is somehow hindering Debo’s effectiveness.
- While Kittle’s individual skills are praised, the conversation suggests that his presence is limiting Debo’s opportunities, leading to a disappointing score of only 10 points for the 49ers’ offense.
- There’s speculation about how certain tight ends have not been getting the ball enough, indicating a possible mismanagement of player targets, even mentioning players like Austin Hooper and Hunter Henry who had varied levels of success.
Quarterback Performance and Matchups 51:30
“Kyler didn’t throw a touchdown, had one called back on penalty.”
- The analysis shifts to quarterback Kyler Murray, who faced a solid defense but struggled, finishing without a touchdown while facing penalties that impacted his scoring opportunities.
- Jared Goff is also discussed, highlighting that he didn’t need to play much, which raises concerns for fantasy players relying on him, particularly as he threw five touchdowns when he was needed the most.
- Anthony Richardson’s performance is examined after a high-scoring previous week, showing that the Lions’ defense posed a significant challenge he couldn’t overcome, showcasing the volatility and unpredictability of quarterback performances from week to week.
Running Backs and Scoring Opportunities 53:41
“Saquon’s got it now.”
- The conversation touches on the changing landscape of running backs, particularly focusing on Joe Mixon and Jonathan Taylor‘s performances against tough defenses.
- Saquon Barkley is noted as reclaiming his position as a top running back following a strong performance, differentiating himself from others who might have struggled due to their matchups.
- A deep dive into Christian McCaffrey’s recent play acknowledges that he hasn’t performed up to par and raises concerns about his long-term viability in the season, questioning his health and productivity as part of a competitive offensive scheme.
Analyzing Underutilized Players 56:53
“The way you win if you’re Arizona is to hand the ball off.”
- The discussion emphasizes the underutilization of running back James Conner within the Cardinals’ offense, which has centered around him in previous games, but faltered due to fewer attempts in this matchup.
- The review of players like Tyrone Tracy raises concerns over fumbles and ineffective yardage, signaling potential trouble for teams relying on them.
- The dynamic of how certain running backs perform drastically relies on the overall offensive abilities and strategies of their teams, especially in tough matchups, leaving fantasy owners frustrated with player output.
Jordan Addison Shines in the Game 59:16
“Addison was awesome.”
- Jordan Addison had an impressive performance that stood out, particularly with a spectacular catch despite being heavily guarded. Many initially mistook his performance for that of Justin Jefferson, showcasing how effectively he played in Jefferson’s absence during a rough stretch.
- Despite Jefferson’s recent struggles, where he ranked as the wide receiver 33, 29, and 60 over the last three weeks, Addison capitalized on the opportunities given to him. He nearly reached 200 yards in this game, proving his capability as a vital offensive player.
- Credit needs to be given to Jalen Johnson, an All-Pro defender, who followed Addison closely throughout the match, indicating the level of competition that Addison managed to overcome.
Impact on Other Players: Hawkinson and the Vikings’ Strategy 01:00:24
“The Vikings did what they should do, which is exploit matchups elsewhere.”
- While Addison excelled, the Vikings effectively utilized other matchups on the field. T.J. Hawkinson also had a notable game, surpassing 100 yards, contributing to a well-rounded offensive strategy.
- This adaptability signifies the Vikings’ ability to recognize when to shift focus from their star player to exploit other weaknesses in the defense, allowing them to maintain a competitive edge in the game.
Wide Receiver Comparisons and Their Performance 01:00:38
“If you chase, you lose.”
- The discussion transitioned to various wide receivers, including Christian Watson and Jalen Waddle, illustrating the risks of placing your trust in inconsistent players for significant game outcomes. Watson’s lack of catches in the recent game was highlighted as disappointing, emphasizing the unpredictable nature of fantasy football performances.
- Observations were made regarding Jaden Reed’s limited targets and performance, indicating that underperformance from key players dramatically affects the dynamic of the game.
Struggles of Key Offensive Players and Injuries 01:02:41
“I think he’s playing hurt.”
- The performance of players like Deebo Samuel and Marvin Harrison Jr. was questioned, with Samuel notably struggling this season under the weight of injuries. Samuel’s playing time has decreased as he acclimates to his health, prompting concerns about his effectiveness on the field.
- Harrison Jr.’s inconsistency was also a focal point, with his lower yardage contributing to frustrations among fantasy managers. The dialogue suggests that while he should be in lineups, his performance should be closely monitored due to the lack of substantial weekly output.
Jameson Williams‘ Target Performance 01:08:54
“Seven targets, five for 64.”
- Jameson Williams had a notable performance with seven targets, catching five passes for a total of 64 yards.
- This performance positioned him as a strong contender among other receivers, potentially leading his team in receptions for the week.
Recent Trends for Williams 01:09:05
“In the last three weeks, since Jameson Williams has come back, he’s had five targets, six targets, seven targets.”
- Over the past three weeks, since his return to the field, Williams has shown an upward trend in target numbers, with games of five, six, and seven targets.
- This increasing trend indicates that Williams is becoming more integrated into the offense and is likely to continue being a significant part of the team’s passing game if the pattern persists.
Upcoming Content and Events 01:09:17
“Make sure to tune in on Wednesday for our megalodon episode.”
- The podcast will host a special “megalodon” episode, combining Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday shows into one large installment.
- This episode marks the 10th anniversary of the megalodon series, and it will offer unique content along with exclusive giveaways for listeners.
- Listeners are encouraged to participate and enjoy the festivities planned for the special event.