Mock Draft Episode + Preseason Takeaways
Fantasy Football show for Aug 8, 2025. Draft strategies tested for the 2025 fantasy football season! Andy, Mike, Jason, and the Footballers team battle it out in a 12-team mock draft! Find out which players are the biggest values in fantasy football drafts. Plus, reactions to the first night of preseason action! Manage your redraft, keeper, and dynasty fantasy football teams with the #1 fantasy football podcast.
2025 ULTIMATE DRAFT KIT + Draft Analyzer available now at UltimateDraftKit.com
Connect with the show:
- Subscribe on YouTube
- Visit us on the Web
- Support the Show
- Follow on X
- Follow on Instagram
- Join our Discord
Summary:
Preseason Takeaways and Notable Performances 00:59
“For those of you hoping for a repeat situation in Cincinnati, I think you will be comforted by what took place last night.”
- The Fantasy Footballers begin by discussing the latest preseason games, highlighting the impressive performance of the Cincinnati offense. Last night’s game showcased their potential, drawing comparisons to previous successful seasons.
- A significant moment involved an entire starting defense struggling against a backup offense in Philadelphia, which raises questions about the team’s readiness.
- Jamar Chase continues to impress with his athleticism, reinforcing his status among the top wide receivers in fantasy football.
- There were mentions of rookie player Jalen Milrow, who showcased speed and accuracy that could make him a compelling option in dynasty leagues. His performance sparked conversations about potential changes in Seattle’s starting quarterback position if Sam Darnold struggles.
Quarterbacks and Rookie Dynamics 02:49
“If Darnold goes 2-4 to start the season… you could absolutely see a replacement happen.”
- The discussion transitions to the quarterback situation in Seattle, where Sam Darnold‘s performance is under scrutiny.
- There is speculation about Milrow’s potential to step in as a starter, especially if Darnold struggles early in the season. This situation is seen as precarious, where the dynamics of playing time could shift quickly.
- The hosts also reflect on the importance of first and second down for running backs and how such statistics can determine a player’s success during crucial game moments.
Additional Player Insights 06:14
“Taj Brooks played every snap with the starters… it was really nice to see.”
- Taj Brooks made a strong impression in the preseason game, playing all snaps with the starting unit, although no big plays were recorded.
- Discussions also touched on other players, like Torrey Horton, who is competing for a starting wide receiver position in Seattle, showing promise by his consistent performance in training camp and the preseason.
- There are concerns regarding Pirine’s role with the Bengals, especially regarding his utilization in third-down situations, yet it is suggested that this should not significantly deter interest in Chase Brown.
Injury News in the NFL 10:40
“Rashawn Slater just signed a four-year, over a hundred million dollar deal, but he tore his patellar tendon.”
- Rashawn Slater, an offensive lineman for the Chargers, recently suffered a significant injury by tearing his patellar tendon. This injury is particularly concerning, as statistics indicate that about 70% of players who sustain this specific injury do not return to their previous form.
- With Slater’s absence, the Chargers’ offensive line, which was previously projected to be one of the best in the league, will have to undergo adjustments. The rookie Joe Alt will be stepping in to play left tackle, a position formerly held by Slater, creating more flux in the team’s offensive structure.
- Despite the loss of Slater, it’s noted that the overall quality of the offensive line should still remain fairly strong, although the injury certainly dampens optimism regarding their potential for the season.
Preseason Player Updates 11:50
“Lad McConkie is still not practicing due to an undisclosed injury.”
- Player injuries and their implications were discussed, with highlights on several key players. Lad McConkie has not participated in practice since late July due to an undisclosed injury, raising concerns about his readiness for the upcoming season.
- Keenan Allen‘s impressive performance in practice was also noted, particularly a moment where he had to leap over an obstacle, showcasing his agility despite not being fully health-conscious on the field.
- Other injury updates included rookie running back Jaden Blue, who left practice with fears of a severe ankle injury but was later confirmed to have only a bone bruise, which is good news for his health moving forward.
- The discussion also touched upon Tyreek Hill‘s struggle with an oblique injury, with concerns about his mental engagement this season considering his past issues and current injuries.
Fantasy Football Considerations 14:45
“Tyreek Hill feels like he’s going to be the best or just a terrible pick.”
- The conversation shifted towards fantasy football implications of these injuries. Tyreek Hill is increasingly seen as a gamble in drafts, especially when compared with other wide receivers like Tee Higgins and Marvin Harrison.
- As he ages and deals with injuries, there is a growing concern regarding Hill’s performance and reliability, making players hesitate to select him early in drafts. The hosts exchanged viewpoints on whether they would choose Hill over other promising players in their position, indicating a general trend of favoring younger, more reliable options.
- Ultimately, the unpredictability of Hill’s performance creates a strong debate in the fantasy community about the wisdom of drafting him this season compared to safer options that might not possess his ceiling.
NFL Players and Smelling Salts 18:06
“The NFL will not provide them, but you’re allowed to go buy them yourself if you’re an NFL player.”
- NFL players are permitted to purchase their own smelling salts, even though the league does not supply them. There is some concern that many players overly rely on these substances for stimulation and focus during gameplay.
- George Kittle‘s positive reaction to learning players could bring their own smelling salts highlights the acceptance of this practice among some athletes.
Mock Draft Setup 19:02
“We got a mock draft to get to.”
- The hosts are gearing up for a 12-team half PPR (Points Per Reception) mock draft, featuring a randomized draft order with specific positional requirements.
- This setup includes one quarterback, two running backs, two wide receivers, one tight end, one flex position, and four bench spots, allowing for varied team strategies.
Draft Insights and Decisions 20:11
“I have drafted Jamar Chase at number one overall in this half PPR draft.”
- The first pick of the draft was Jamar Chase, indicating the player’s high value in fantasy football circles. The commentary reveals an excitement around the early choices.
- As the draft progresses, discussions unfold about other top running backs like Bijan Robinson and Jameer Gibbs, with specific attention to player performance and expectations for the upcoming season.
Jahmyr Gibbs Discussion 21:02
“I think if you ask me what running back I would want in my backfield for an NFL team, I would choose Jameer Gibbs.”
- Jameer Gibbs has been discussed as a top-tier running back due to expectations for his performance and offensive fit. The debate centers on whether he can match the volume needed to replicate previous successes without injuries.
- Comparisons are made between Gibbs and Bijan Robinson, emphasizing the potential of both players, although Gibbs is noted for being able to elevate his team’s performance significantly.
Player Value and Injury Concerns 22:00
“If David Montgomery does what he’s done for every year they’ve been together, you’re not going to be happy.”
- There is consideration of how David Montgomery‘s presence may impact Gibbs’ value in fantasy drafts, based on past performance splits.
- The hosts express concern over the Lions’ new coaching decisions and their possible effects on player performance, especially considering the history of injuries of Gibbs.
Mock Draft Execution and Player Choices 25:33
“I was very curious in this draft when the trigger gets pulled on Puka Nakua.”
- The mock draft reveals strategic choices by the participants, including an interest in Puka Nakua and Devon A-Chan. This reflects broader trends in player selection and positioning in fantasy drafts.
- Participants discuss player reliability and the impact of associated quarterback situations on their decision-making, especially regarding Jonathan Taylor‘s value as a top fantasy pick.
Quarterback Concerns and Draft Strategy 27:19
“I just worry about touchdowns and whether that’s really going to be a part of… the touchdowns from an offensive standpoint of whether the team is good enough.”
- There are concerns regarding the quarterback situation affecting touchdown production. The offense’s overall quality will play a significant role in determining the success of players in scoring opportunities.
- The presence of multiple quarterbacks capable of rushing touchdowns raises the risk of potential touchdown vulturing, especially near the goal line. This is a critical point to consider when drafting offensive players.
Drafting Strategy and Tiers of Players 27:51
“This draft has steamed up the running backs.”
- The draft has seen a noticeable shift in the value of running backs, with players like Chase Brown and Kyron Williams typically going in the third round now being picked earlier due to demand.
- The speaker indicates that their strategy involves recognizing this shift and reacting accordingly in their draft choices, highlighting the importance of staying aware of the changing landscape during the drafting process.
Tight End Decision-Making 28:03
“If I don’t take one of the premier tight ends with one of these two picks… I will have no shot at either one of them.”
- The importance of selecting a premier tight end early in the draft is emphasized, as missing out could result in no opportunity to secure top options like George Kittle or Trey McBride later in the draft.
- The speaker evaluates their overall strategy, weighing the need for a tight end against other positional needs, showing the strategic balancing act that is essential in mock drafting.
Response to Changing Player Values 29:49
“When we started this, I feel like a month ago, [Kittle] was a fifth-rounder.”
- Player values can fluctuate significantly leading up to a draft. For instance, George Kittle‘s expected draft position has moved from the fifth round to potentially the third round.
- The speaker notes that this trend indicates a growing demand for elite tight ends, which can influence drafting decisions and strategies in fantasy football.
Defensive Draft Tactics and Player Evaluation 31:38
“At this point, … when you’re sitting there with Jamar Chase on your team, it’s just like a no-brainer.”
- Drafting involves making hard decisions about positional stacking and evaluating player relationships, such as drafting Joe Burrow when already having Jamar Chase on the roster.
- The “stacking” strategy is mentioned, demonstrating that knowing player synergy can enhance a team’s potential, emphasizing the importance of strategic thinking and foresight in fantasy football drafts.
Drafting Strategy for Rookies and Veterans 36:10
“I’m going to take Ted Aroa McMillan, you would not have gotten him back.”
- During the mock draft, the focus was on weighing options between rookie players and seasoned veterans. The decision to draft Ted Aroa McMillan indicates a strategy to target high-upside rookies that may not be available later in the draft. This reflects a balance between securing reliable veterans like Cortland Sutton and looking for promising newcomers with potential.
Evaluating Risk in Player Selection 37:27
“If we believe in Bo Nix at all, then Cortland Sutton is going to have an incredible year.”
- The discussion emphasizes weighing past performances against potential future outcomes. There are concerns regarding Cortland Sutton’s past frustrations in terms of performance, but optimism remains based on quarterback Bo Nix‘s prospects. This highlights the need for players to assess both historical data and current team dynamics when making draft choices.
Selecting Players in High-Risk Positions 37:46
“I got to add some probably some veteran starters later in the draft.”
- Some players expressed the need for caution with their selections, particularly noting the risk associated with young running backs like Caleb Johnson. Balancing these risky picks with reliable veterans can create a more stable fantasy roster, especially in a long season where injuries frequently occur.
The Importance of Timing in Player Picks 40:56
“You got to take the guys you want; you can’t play the ADP game.”
- A critical highlight is the emphasis on the timing and urgency of player selections, especially for those drafting at the turn. Waiting could result in losing desired players, leading to the recommendation to draft key targets earlier if necessary, rather than relying solely on average draft position (ADP) trends.
Evaluating Value of Wide Receivers 39:22
“I think if Waddle stays healthy, I just don’t see that much of a differential between them.”
- The analysis on the value of wide receiver Jalen Waddle reveals a keen insight into market perception. The variance in draft position between Waddle and other high-profile receivers like Tyreek Hill emphasizes the importance of health and the opportunity players have within their teams.
Tight End Decisions and Player Upside 45:32
“I’m going to take him over just the baseline of Hawkinson.”
- The discussion revolves around the choice between tight ends T.J. Hawkinson and David Njoku, with an emphasis on Njoku’s potential for significant upside depending on Joe Flacco‘s performance.
- The speaker expresses a belief in Njoku’s potential over the safer pick of Hawkinson, indicating a preference for players who can exceed expectations rather than simply meeting baseline projections.
Zero RB Strategy and Draft Dynamics 46:15
“Your team is not like, it looks gross at the draft, but it’s all about shaping it as the season goes on.”
- A commentary on the Zero RB drafting strategy shows that while the initial roster may appear weak, success relies on in-season management and adjustments.
- This strategy emphasizes flexibility and adaptability, as owners focus on building depth and identifying value in later rounds rather than relying on solid running backs early on.
Picking Wide Receivers and Team Depth 46:50
“I’m going to double tap the wide receiver position here.”
- The speaker plans to select two wide receivers, Keenan Allen and Chris Godwin, to strengthen the roster’s depth.
- Choosing Allen in the eighth round and potentially placing Godwin on the physically unable to perform (PUP) list highlights a strategy of capitalizing on available talent while considering injury management and future game participation.
Late-round Tight End Targets and Value Picks 50:00
“David Njoku, my usual late-round tight end target.”
- The late-round pick of David Njoku illustrates a common tactic of selecting known quantities that have a chance of capitalizing on their situation.
- The mention of Tyler Warren as a potential breakout option emphasizes the desire for a tight end that could outperform expectations while considering ceiling versus floor in drafting choices.
Draft Strategy Insights 54:48
“They do not have enough players on the offensive side of the football.”
- The mock draft emphasizes the need to avoid players from teams that lack a strong offensive lineup. This could put fantasy players at a disadvantage, as fewer scoring opportunities may affect player performance.
- There is a discussion around Kyle Pitts, with a prevailing sentiment that positive buzz may be misleading. The speaker suggests a cautious approach to drafting him.
Running Back Considerations 55:02
“I want to plug in some early starters while Caleb Johnson gets going.”
- The focus is on securing running backs from ambiguous backfields within effective offensive systems. The strategy is to choose players who are poised to earn significant playing time as the season progresses.
- A pick of Austin Eckler from the Washington Commanders is cited as part of this strategy, emphasizing the pursuit of running backs who can immediately impact the team.
Final Draft Picks & Notable Team Compositions 55:48
“I ended up with Jamar Chase at the one-on-one.”
- The drafting teams share their final selections, highlighting key players like Jamar Chase, Trey McBride, and Joe Burrow. This reflects a strategy that involves crafting a stacked roster, particularly at critical positions like wide receiver and quarterback.
- The speaker outlines the necessity of securing good depth in both the running back and wide receiver positions, indicating a balanced roster approach.
Upcoming Content and Community Engagement 57:16
“We have a special mini-series that will be going live every Saturday.”
- The channel promotes additional content available for viewers, like a special mini-series aimed at giving fantasy football advice and insights leading up to the season.
- The community is invited to subscribe for regular updates and to engage with the content, underscoring the importance of staying informed as the season starts.

