Evaluating the 2018 WR Draft Class (Fantasy Football)
As I immerse myself deeper and deeper into dynasty leagues, I find myself evaluating fantasy football from a bigger picture point of view. But I’m not just doing this to try to improve as a dynasty player. I believe these kinds of exercises can help us grow as fantasy players of all formats – redraft, best ball, DFS, etc. because they allow us to better project and predict career breakout seasons.
In a three-part series, I’m comparing all first-year players over the past three seasons in receiving yards per game. All players that hit at least 20 yards per game are listed in the below table. I’m evaluating notable players from all three years separately. See my breakdown of the 2017 class here.
I’m discussing trends and how I see values heading into 2020. All ADPs were gathered from FFPC Best Ball Classic drafts over the past two weeks. Some notable players that didn’t make the 20 receiving yards per game cut will also be addressed. Now let’s break down the 2018 class:
|Equanimeous St. Brown||2018||22||12||36||21||328||27.3|
Notable 2018 Players That Make The List
Ridley ranks ninth on this list and first out of all WRs from the 2018 class. He followed up his rookie year with an improved sophomore season posting 66.6 receiving yards per game in 13 contests. His outlook couldn’t look much better heading into 2020. Ridley plays for an average Falcons team that will need to throw a lot to remain competitive and is in an offense that can get it done through the air as they ranked second in the league in passing yards per game in 2019. His target projection looks strong with Mohamed Sanu long gone and Atlanta downgrading at TE from Austin Hooper to Hayden Hurst.
Basically the entire fantasy football community understands this as Ridley has a fourth-round (45.2) redraft ADP. I don’t have an issue with that cost but don’t feel comfortable pushing him up any higher. Ridley is a strong player but not an elite one. Julio Jones has at least one more alpha-male WR1 season in him. I prefer Julio to Ridley, even when factoring in ADP. In dynasty, Ridley is a solid hold but also an intriguing sell at possibly the highest value he’ll ever have. Yes, Julio is getting older but so is Matt Ryan. Ryan is 35 years old.
I’m not sure I could have any Moore love for D.J. from a dynasty perspective and I’m a big fan in redraft as well. Moore followed up a solid rookie season with an incredible sophomore year, totaling 1,175 receiving yards playing with Kyle Allen of all QBs. Only 23 years old, Moore’s talent will collide with an almost perfect fantasy environment to crush in 2020.
New Head Coach Matt Rhule brings excitement to the offense, Teddy Bridgewater is an upgrade at QB, and Carolina’s defense is set up to be historically bad. You’d have to pry Moore away from my cold, dead hands in order to get him from me in dynasty. And smash the draft button every time at Moore’s early fourth-round (37.6) ADP in redraft.
Kirk is a really intriguing evaluation at this point. Kirk posted over 1,000 receiving yards as an 18-year old freshman at Texas A&M and has started his NFL career with 590 and 709 receiving yard seasons, respectively. There’s no doubt in my mind Kirk can play and the third-year breakout could very well be coming this season.
However, things are a bit messy as DeAndre Hopkins was brought in this offseason, Larry Fitzgerald just won’t go away, and second (Andy Isabella) and fourth-round (Hakeem Butler) picks from 2019 are waiting in the wings. That normally would be enough for me to pass in redraft. However, his current ADP is in the tenth-round (117.7) and at that cost, I’m willing to take a chance.
The Cardinals’ offense is exciting and trending up in Year 2 with Kliff Kingsbury and Kyler Murray steering the ship and their defense, although improving, projects to be average at best. I’m a big fan of owning Kirk in dynasty and think now is a great time to buy.
Coutee is a sad case for me. He only posted 287 receiving yards as a rookie but he did it in only six games due to injuries and even posted 11 receptions for 110 yards and a TD in his only playoff game. He did this after totaling 2,319 receiving yards in his age 19 and 20 sophomore and junior seasons. So I had high hopes for him heading into 2019.
Unfortunately, he only played in nine games and totaled 254 receiving yards. Stuck behind Brandin Cooks, Kenny Stills, and Randall Cobb, Coutee is completely off the redraft radar. Health is a major concern but Coutee is still an intriguing dynasty stash because when he’s been on the field, he’s proven he offers weekly upside.
Sutton is that dude. A true alpha WR1, Sutton has totaled 1,816 yards through his first two seasons in the NFL playing with these QBs: Case Keenum, Joe Flacco, Brandon Allen, and Drew Lock. He has plenty of target competition at this point with Jerry Jeudy, K.J. Hamler, and Noah Fant but make no mistake, Sutton is still currently the Broncos’ WR1.
Sutton is a strong asset in dynasty and is acquirable due to his questionable QB situation and target competition. Go get him now as I see him being a star for years to come. Things are murky in redraft due to the issues highlighted above but his fifth-round (54.2) ADP is more than fair.
Gallup proved he’s the real deal last season, blowing up for 1,107 yards in the league’s #2 passing offense. His immediate value took a few hits this offseason, with Dallas signing Amari Cooper long-term and drafting CeeDee Lamb in the first round.
But these developments have made Gallup more acquirable in dynasty and mean he now has an eighth-round redraft ADP. Drafters really seem to be on top of things this offseason because once again, that sounds right to me. The Cowboys lost numerous defensive stars, including Byron Jones and Robert Quinn, this offseason and project to lean heavily on their passing game for the second year in a row.
Tre’Quan is worth mentioning because he plays for the Saints in Sean Payton‘s offense and totaled 427 yards as a rookie. With Emmanuel Sanders in town, he’s off the redraft radar entirely but he’s an intriguing low-cost stash in dynasty. His stock would increase dramatically if he became the Saints’ WR2 in the future with possibly Jameis Winston at QB.
Miller is the perfect dynasty target this offseason. He posted seasons of 1,434 and 1,462 receiving yards respectively as a junior and senior at Memphis and then followed that up with totaling 1,079 receiving yards in his first two years in the league playing with Mitchell Trubisky.
Taylor Gabriel was released, no legitimate WRs were brought in this offseason, and Nick Foles is likely going to provide an upgrade at QB for the Bears. As the clear-cut WR2 in an offense with questionable TEs, Miller’s 14th-round (161.3) ADP makes for a great value.
Notable Players Not Listed
After totaling 4,016 receiving yards in his final three years at Oklahoma State, Washington surprisingly only had 217 receiving yards as a rookie. However, he was able to turn that around last year and post 735 receiving yards while competing with JuJu Smith-Schuster and Diontae Johnson and dealing with a horrible QB situation.
Ben Roethlisberger returns this season and that improves the outlook of the entire Steelers’ offense, Washington included. I’m a huge fan of JuJu and really like Diontae Johnson just like everyone else but it’s funny how we’ve all collectively decided Washington is the odd man out, especially since he led the Steelers in receiving yards last year.
I’ll just leave these numbers here. 2020 Redraft ADP: JuJu fourth-round (38.3), Diontae ninth-round (102.1), and Washington 21st-round (251.2). 2019 targets and receiving yards per game: JuJu 5.8 and 46, Diontae 5.8 and 42.5, and Washington 5.3 and 49. Chase Claypool beating James Washington out for snaps is an extreme assumption at this point.
The contrast between Chark’s rookie season and last year is actually pretty hilarious. Chark went from posting 174 receiving yards as a rookie to 1,008 yards last season. Chark runs a 4.34 40-yard dash, plays on a horrible Jaguars’ team that will have to throw a ton on a weekly basis to stay competitive, and now has passing-game friendly, Jay Gruden, as his Offensive Coordinator.
Chris Conley, Dede Westbrook, and second-round pick Laviska Shenault don’t provide the toughest target competition either. His sixth-round (61.4) ADP is more than fair. Chark isn’t a target of mine in either redraft or dynasty, but I don’t fault others getting more aggressive.