It’s time to reflect on the elite of fantasy signal-callers to find out the TRUTH behind their end of year stat lines and fantasy finishes. Patrick Mahomes was the clear eye-opener but which other top-5 guys actually helped your fantasy team out and were consistent?

Check out previous TRUTH episodes including RBs and WRs. Get the full QB breakdown from Andy, Mike, and Jason on the podcast: Part 1 / Part 2.

The TRUTH Scoring

Player finish, fantasy points, and consistency percentages are based on a minimum 6 games started and based on 4 points per passing TD leagues. Game splits based on 6 points per passing TD leagues.

Great Games are more than 25 points (top 3 on average)
Good Games are more than 17 points (top 12 on average)
Bust Games are fewer than 15 points (outside top 16 on average)

1. Patrick Mahomes – Consistency Rank #1

16 games — 383/580 for 5097/50/12 — 60/272/2 rushing
Great 63% | Good 93% | Bust 0%

Defenses: +0.16 vs Top 16 Pass DEF
10 weeks vs Top 16 (32.56)/6 weeks vs Bot 16 (32.40)
Home (27.44)/Road (37.57) Split: -10.13 at Home

There are too many exclamation points to give on fantasy’s #1 QB, #1 consistent QB, and the likely league MVP. He tied Peyton Manning‘s magical 2013 season with 14 QB1 weeks for the most in history. The question is how Mahomes’ earth0shattering performance translates to next year. What he did this year was worth an early round pick. However, going into 2019, where should he be drafted? Since 2004 there hasn’t been a repeat QB1 and his TD % of 8.6 is almost impossible to repeat.

2. Matt Ryan – Consistency Rank #2

16 games — 422/608 for 4924/35/7 — 33/125/3 — rushing
Great 44% | Good 75% | Bust 25%

Defenses: -12.47 vs Top 16 Pass DEF
7 weeks vs Top 16 (20.34)/9 weeks vs Bot 16 (32.81)
Home (29.22)/Road (25.49) Split: +3.73 at Home

After a putrid Week 1 performance against the Eagles, Matt Ryan was incredible. From Weeks 2-10, he averaged the same amount of fantasy points as Patrick Mahomes including 7 QB1 performances. He, in fact, posted the 14th best fantasy QB season of all-time aided by a career-high 3 rushing TDs AND a receiving TD. With another offensive coordinator switch, things could change next year in Atlanta. The running game was putrid and Devonta Freeman was out for most of the year. He is a surefire top-10 selection with a draft price that could creep into the double-digit rounds.

3. Ben Roethlisberger – Consistency Rank #5

16 games — 452/675 for 5129/34/16 — 31/98/3 rushing
Great 25% | Good 69% | Bust 25%

Defenses: -8.43 vs Top 16 Pass DEF
7 weeks vs Top 16 (21.51)/9 weeks vs Bot 16 (29.94)
Home (26.36)/Road (26.15) Split: +0.21 at Home

Historically Big Ben has been rough on the road but his splits were almost identical. The emergence of Juju Smith-Schuster helped immensely. Roethlisberger had 8 top-10 weeks and paced the league with 5,129 passing yards, the most of his career. Moving forward, Antonio Brown‘s status will be worth monitoring on Roethlisberger’s 2019 draft price.

Mark Alberti/ Icon Sportswire

4.  Deshaun Watson – Consistency Rank #3

16 games — 345/505 for 4165/26/9 — 99/551/5 rushing
Great 31% | Good 69% | Bust 25%

Defenses: -2.37 vs Top 16 Pass DEF
10 weeks vs Top 16 (29.94)/6 weeks vs Bot 16 (26.82)
Home (25.48)/Road (25.19) Split: +0.29 at Home

Watson was the second QB selected in drafts at the 36th overall pick and yet still you didn’t get the return on your investment. While showcasing a ceiling, he sprinkled in some games that ultimately killed your team. He holds the ball sometimes forever correlating to being sacked 62 times, the most since Jon Kitna in 2006. His baseline with the rushing will be there and he improved his accuracy with the highest completion percentage (68.3%) for a 2nd year QB in NFL History. There will be debates which upper-tier QB would be taken over him in 2019 drafts. His pairing with DeAndre Hopkins ultimately makes him an elite option for the coming years.

5.  Andrew Luck – Consistency Rank #4

16 games — 430/639 for 4593/39/15 — 46/148/0
Great 6% | Good 75% | Bust 25%

Defenses: -4.99 vs Top 16 Pass DEF
9 weeks vs Top 16 (23.41)/7 weeks vs Bot 16 (28.4)
Home (27.69)/Road (23.49) Split: +4.2 at Home

This was a year where Luck was criticized in the beginning for his supposed “lack” of arm-strength and recovery from injury. He was solid including an NFL-record 8 straight games with 3 or more passing TDs from Weeks 4-12. He finished with the highest QB Rating (98.7) of his career and with a revamped offensive line, he had the lowest sack rate (2.7%) in the league.


For the rest of the QBs included the TRUTH episodes, check out Part 2 on Thursday.


Comments from the community:

  1. Bradnr says:

    Would love to see the # of games or percentage of games in the Great Good Bust categories like you did with RBs and WRs. Thanks - LOVE these TRUTH analyses!!!

  2. Just updated QB articles to include these percentages. Oversight by me :man_facepalming:

    Thanks for the feedback!

  3. Bradnr says:

    I very much appreciate it. I use these stats A LOT come draft time. Just ordered the 2019 draft kit KEEEEYAAAAAWWWW

Leave a Comment

Others talking about this: