The TRUTH About Top-10 QBs in 2023 (Fantasy Football)

On Thursday’s Fantasy Footballers podcast, Andy, Mike, and Jason took an in-depth look at the top-10 QBs from the 2023 season and dived into the reality of their fantasy finishes and whether they actually helped fantasy managers win titles.

You can watch the whole episode on YouTube here:

Here is how our TRUTH Data algorithm breaks down player performance from the season. In 4-point passing TD leagues:

• Great Games are more than 26 points.
• Good Games are more than 21 points.
• Bust Games are fewer than 15 points.
• Missed Games don’t count against consistency score.

This article is meant as a quick reference point to use all off-season along with our Weekly Snapshot Tool.

1. Josh Allen | Bills

Age: 27.6 |  ADP: 2.09 / QB2

Unlock Exclusive Tools + Bonus Episode

Join the FootClan

17 games – 385/579 for 4306/29/18 — 111/524/15 rushing TDs

2023 Consistency Rank: 1

1st Half: 1 / 2nd Half: 1

• Great: 24%
• Good: 76%
• Bust: 18%

2. Jalen Hurts | Eagles

Age: 25.4 |  ADP: 2.11 / QB3

17 games – 352/538 for 3858/23/15 — 157/605/15 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: 2 (*Week 18 not counted in consistency score)

1st Half: 2 / 2nd Half: 10

• Great: 19%
• Good: 63%
• Bust: 13%

3. Lamar Jackson | Ravens

Age: 27 |  ADP: 3.10 / QB4

Unlock Exclusive Tools + Bonus Episode

Join the FootClan

16 games – 307/457 for 3678/24/7 – 148/821/5 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: 4 (*Ravens benched starters in Week 18)

1st Half: 6 / 2nd Half: 2

• Great: 31%
• Good: 50%
• Bust: 38%

4. Dak Prescott | Cowboys

Age: 30.4 |  ADP: 8.08 / QB10

17 games – 410/590 for 4516/36/9 – 55/242/2 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: Tied-8th

1st Half: 15 / 2nd Half: 6

• Great: 29%
• Good: 47%
• Bust: 29%

5. Jordan Love | Packers

Age: 25.2 |  ADP: 16.09 / QB22

Unlock Exclusive Tools + Bonus Episode

Join the FootClan

17 games – 372/579 for 4159/32/11 — 50/247/4 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: Tied-8th (with Dak)

1st Half: 14 / 2nd Half: 7

• Great: 12%
• Good: 47%
• Bust: 24%

Michael Reaves/Getty Images

6. Brock Purdy | 49ers

Age: 24.0 |  ADP: 14.05 / QB18

16 games – 308/444 for 4280/31/11 — 39/144 /2 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: 6 (*did not play Week 18)

1st Half: 9 / 2nd Half: 5

• Great: 19%
• Good: 50%
• Bust: 31%

7. Patrick Mahomes | Chiefs 

Age: 28.3 |  ADP: 2.03 / QB1

Unlock Exclusive Tools + Bonus Episode

Join the FootClan

16 games – 401/597 for 4183/27/14 – 75/389/0 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: 17 (*Did not play Week 18)

1st Half: 12 / 2nd Half: 16

• Great: 6%
• Good: 25%
• Bust: 31%

8. Jared Goff | Lions

Age: 29.2 |  ADP: 13.09 / QB17

17 games – 407/605 for 4575/30/12 – 32/21/2 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: 10

1st Half: 7 / 2nd Half: 14

• Great: 12%
• Good: 35%
• Bust: 47%

9. Baker Mayfield | Buccaneers

Age: 28.8 |  ADP: 22.03 / QB33

Unlock Exclusive Tools + Bonus Episode

Join the FootClan

17 games – 364/566 for 4044/28/10 – 62/163/1 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: 21

1st Half: 18 / 2nd Half: 18

• Great: 6%
• Good: 24%
• Bust: 35%

10. Tua Tagovailoa | Dolphins

Age: 25.8 |  ADP: 8.11 / QB11

Unlock Exclusive Tools + Bonus Episode

Join the FootClan

17 games – 388/560 for 4624/29/14 – 35/74/0 rushing

2023 Consistency Rank: 19

1st Half: 4 / 2nd Half: 30

• Great: 12%
• Good: 24%
• Bust: 53%