Fantasy Football Saturday Mailbag for Week 11 (Fantasy Football)
Good morning, FootClan, and welcome to Week 11 of The Fantasy Footballers’ Saturday Morning Mailbag! As always, I am here bright and early on Saturday morning to select a few of your questions from The Fantasy Footballers’ Discord server and answer some of the hot topics that didn’t quite make it to that week’s edition of The Footcast. The Ballers’ Discord is home to the biggest and best online fantasy football community in the world, and is your go-to if you are looking to talk about all things fantasy football. Head over today and get involved with thousands of members across dozens of dedicated channels for start/sit questions, trade advice, and waiver wire insights, as well as exclusive areas that are only available to members of the FootClan.
Welcome to the Bye-pocalypse FootClan! Week 11 is finally upon us, and although we have known for months that this day was coming…it doesn’t make it any easier now that it has arrived. If you have been flying high with players from the Packers, Rams, Seahawks, Patriots, or the Falcons, then I hope you have got some useful plug-and-play options, as there are no Jordan Love, Christian Watson, Matthew Golden, Kyren Williams, Blake Corum, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Rhamondre Stevenson, Drake London, or Bijan Robinson. The Browns are also on a bye…but if you are playoff-bound with those guys on your roster, you are having your very own “Year of Mike” levels of good vibes. In a week where we’ve lost another QB for the year in Drake Maye and Puka Nacua got suspended for games that he was never going to play, there was still plenty going on around the National Football League. We have got a lot to cover…so let’s dive right in!
Question #1 – Trade Talk (RB Upgrade Special)

IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Hey Ballers! I just sent away Harold Fannin Jr. and D’Andre Swift for James Cook in my Full-PPR league. I still have Trey McBride at TE…did I overpay? – Never Go Full Cobb
Answer: If you are a regular reader of the Saturday Morning Mailbag (and if you are not…where have you been?), you will be more than aware of my infatuation- nay, borderline obsession – with the Chicago Bears RB1. A My Guy, a Fantasy Court defendant and the King of Consistency – D’Andre Swift has deserved all the praise that has come his way this season (most of it from me), as he currently sits as the overall RB12 on the year…even after his bye week.
So to see that you have traded him away casts a 5’8”, 204lbs shadow over my soul…but to see you have done so alongside Harold Fannin Jr. in return for James Cook softens the blow somewhat.
Let’s look at the TE first. There is a saying here we use in Scotland: “Nae Twa Doots” (which essentially means “make no doubt about it”), so when referring to Browns’ TE Fannin, there’s nae twa doots that he has been on somewhat of a heater in recent weeks, with back-to-back-to-back top-6 finishes over the last three weeks, scoring double-digit fantasy points in his last four. What is arguably more impressive from the sophomore out of Bowling Green is that he has hit these lofty heights without finding the end zone too often. The go-to pass-catcher for both Deshaun Watson and Shedeur Sanders, Fannin has gone over 90 receiving yards in three out of those four contests…with the only game he didn’t go beyond that threshold being the one where he found pay dirt.
Fannin is a great example of how a star name – or lack of one – can influence perception. Heading into Week 11, the 22-year-old (yes, he’s still that young) has 44 receptions on 62 targets, for 544 yards and four TDs, enough to see him sit as the overall TE5 this year. The TE4 – George Kittle – also has 44 receptions on 62 targets, totaling a mere 13 more yards than Fanning and a single additional TD…yet I can almost guarantee Brock Purdy’s number one guy will fetch a significantly higher trade price than the man catching passes from the NFL’s most despised QB (no, not you, Daniel Jones). Despite the hatred for Watson, he is playing remarkably well for a guy who hadn’t thrown a ball in almost two years – with Cleveland sitting at 11th in total passing attempts and 10th in passing yards, and with Fannin looking at the seventh-best rest-of-season strength of schedule, an argument could be made for him breaking into the top three when all is done and dusted come the end of the year. All that said…he is still just a TE, and being able to turn him and a fringe RB1 – who will see his much younger, and more explosive running mate return from a five-week absence – into James Cook is a very good bit of business for your fantasy team.

The Bills only have the 18th best ROS strength of schedule…but it is the Buffalo Bills, so matchups can usually go out the window. Only Jahmyr Gibbs has more rushing attempts or yards so far this year than James Cook, and with only the 49ers and Bengals scoring more TDs, it is a relatively safe bet that Cook and the Bills will continue to score championship-winning levels of points from here on in. You took your backup TE behind Trey McBride and an RB whose efficiency has dropped week-on-week for a month, and turned them into the likely RB3 of the season…you did good, kid, very good.
Question #2 – Season-long Strategy (Back It Up Edition)

IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Yo Yo Ballers! I’m sitting at 7-3 and am basically a lock for the playoffs. Should I drop Kaelon Black for Sione Vaki as the Jahmyr Gibbs owner? – Mulegator12
Answer: First things first, congrats on being 7-3. The playoffs are on the horizon and it very much sounds as if you have already booked your ticket to the Wild Card round at least, great job. While you cannot lose sight of the importance of the next few weeks, now is definitely the time to turn one eye towards Weeks 15-17 and start to bolster your roster to be as strong as possible for the final push in December. Handcuffing RBs is most certainly a solid strategy to ensure your starting lineup stays competitive in the event of an injury to one of your studs…but just because Gibbs is the clear-cut RB1 for fantasy, does that mean we need to roster his potential backup in case of an injury? Let’s take a look at the numbers.
Sione Vaki – to those who are not overly familiar with the name – is a third-year back out of Utah, drafted by the Lions in the third round of the 2024 NFL Draft. Coming into the year, Vaki had only ten total career touches…with nine of those coming in his rookie season…that’s right, he had just one single touch in 2025 – a 4-yard carry on the second-to-last play in a 44-22 blowout victory over Washington. Remind me again why we should trust this guy? To his credit, the 25-year-old has done fairly well with his limited opportunities so far this season, rushing at 4.5 Y/A on his 36 carries (I hope he butterfly-stretched with this 3600% increase on last season), including a commendable 65 yards on 11 rushes against a stout Vikings defense back in Week 8. As the only RB on the roster with more than two rushing attempts in the opening ten weeks, it is probably safe to assume that Vaki would take on the lead-back role for Detroit and garner the lion’s share (pun fully intended) of carries in Dan Campbell’s high-powered, high-T offense. Given his relative inexperience, the Lions would undoubtedly work in sophomore UDFA Jacob Saylors, aka “Sailor Jerry,” and UDFA rookie Jabari Small, as well as potentially bring in a veteran from another practice squad, or off the streets (if it worked for the Saints and Audric Estime, it can work for the Lions!). Vaki undoubtedly has value, but he would be an RB2 with upside at best.
Contrast this with Kaelon Black of the San Francisco 49ers, who – despite being a rookie – has already carved out a role for himself in Kyle Shanahan’s RB-friendly system…and, more importantly, avoided the clutches of the sub-station at their training facility, which has claimed so many groins and hamstrings so far this season. After an alarm-bell ringing 14 rushing attempts in Week 1 (fellow Christian McCaffrey managers were undoubtedly joining me in tilting off the face of the planet), the third-round rookie out of Indiana saw his workload shrink, and we all assumed this was just part of the plan to ramp up CMC heading into the year. While that was partially true, Black has seen double-digit carries in San Francisco’s last three games – rushing at a very impressive 5.5 Y/A on his 34 opportunities. A small sample size, sure, but that’s a 17-game pace of 1,054 yards and 11 TDs…and that’s with CMC playing. Black has scored on runs of 25 and 30 yards in that three-game stretch and has looked explosive in the process. Where there is some doubt if Vaki could step into Jahmyr Gibbs’ very big shoes, ain’t nobody questioning that Kaelon Black would immediately vault into an RB1-level conversation should CMC need to miss any time.
Even as the Gibbs manager, I would rather be rostering Black heading into the playoffs. At worst, I have a player I can FLEX right now even with McCaffrey on the field, and at best…I have another RB1 to complement Gibbs on my way to a #FootClanTitle.
Question #3 – Trade Talk (TE Tales of Woe Edition)

IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Sup Ballers? I am WR-heavy right now, and I need to upgrade at TE. Would you trade any of the following away for a TE? Malik Nabers, Christian Watson, Parker Washington, or Justin Jefferson – Obi-Wan
Answer: Obi-Wan, I am the Fantasy Footballer writer you are looking for, as I currently have three of these four WRs rostered in my league of record, and I can tell you with absolutely no reservations…there is a zero-percent chance I am trading away any of them for a TE, even if I am desperate.
As a fellow Nabers, Jefferson and Watson owner (curse you, Scott, for rejecting my Parker Washington trade offers), I can understand the temptation to move one of them on for a superstar at the TE position…but even though rostering four elite wideouts may result in a weekly selection headache, it just doesn’t feel as if there are any TEs worthy of trading for with such high player-capital. Had you asked this a couple of weeks ago, then sure, send out offers for one of these guys for Brock Bowers or Trey McBride and say a little prayer, but now…I do not know how much better those two behemoths of the position will be than the George Kittles or Isaiah Likely’s of this world.
For a seven-week spell, Bowers was lapping the field at the pass-catching onesie position, averaging 17.4 FPPG in 0.5-PPR scoring – a whopping 4.2 FPPG ahead of the TE2 over the same period of time: Trey McBride. Bowers was so dominant that the gap between him and the Cardinals’ leading pass-catcher was the same between McBride as the TE2 and Tucker Kraft all the way down at TE8…super-human. Unfortunately, even Superman has his weaknesses, and Brock Bowers’ appears to be his right knee and ankle, the latter being the cause of this latest stint on the sidelines…the same injury that ruled him out of two games in his Junior year at Georgia back in 2023. Whereas Bowers’ plight should be short-term, Trey McBride’s QB woes do not look like they will improve anytime soon. As if having rookie Carson Beck throwing him the ball wasn’t damaging enough for last year’s TE1 fantasy value, it appears as if Josh Johnson may be getting the start this week, with Beck also sidelined with a back injury.
If you are sitting reading this and thinking to yourself “that name Josh Johnson sounds familiar”, then it may be because the dude has been in the league for over eighteen (18) years! The definition of a journeyman: since being drafted in the fifth round of the 2008 NFL Draft by the then San Diego Chargers, Johnson has played for no fewer than 15 different NFL franchises, had a stint in the NFL, won Most Accurate QB in the Alliance of American Football, and took part in the rebirth of the XFL…what a career!
All that to say, am I holding out hopes for Trey McBride with a guy who, for a period of time, was closer to being in the ring with John Cena than he was being on a football field with Tom Brady…absolutely not. If you are feeling adamant about trading for a TE, maybe you could try and flip Nabers for Likely plus a little something else, but legit, Likely and Kittle are the only guys I would be targeting in a trade; otherwise, I’d stick with whatever you’ve got and go full stream ahead from here on in.
It’s time for Rapid Round…
Would you trade away Christian Watson for Bucky Irving if you really needed an RB and a win this week? – KennyGainwell?YesHeKen
Answer: You may have the Bucs’ backup RB in your username, but you should 100% take the opportunity to get their lead back in your fantasy line-up if it happens to introduce itself. Bucky has been playing out of his mind recently, and heading into Tampa’s Week 10 bye, he was the overall RB1 between Weeks 5 and 9, averaging 21.5 FPPG in Half-PPR formats. I love Christian Watson, but Bucky is a top-5 RB ROS…add in your desperation for a win this week and a need at the RB position; this is a no-brainer.

IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Hey, guys! Would you rather have Chase Brown or Bhayshul Tuten ROS in a full PPR redraft? – Wet and Cautious
Answer: Even with his lingering injury, I am leaning Tuten here. He has been one of the most efficient backs on the season – putting up a massive 2.5 Yards After Contact (YACON) on average every time he gets the ball in his hands. Only Bijan Robinson, Kenneth Walker, Jaylen Warren, and Bucky Irving have been running harder among RBs with 100+ carries; Chase Brown, on the other hand, is down at 1.6 YACON per attempt…worse than Ashton Jeanty and Omarion Hampton. The Jacksonville offense is purring; I would lean the Jaguar over the Bengal.
Ballers! If you could pick any U.S. city for your next live event, where would it be? Also, same question but international? – Mmmmitch
Answer: Now, I cannot talk for Andy, Mike and Jason on their individual preferences, but as a Scotsman over the other side of the pond who traveled to Los Angeles for a previous live show…something on the East Coast would be a delight in my opinion. Internationally, well there is only one logical choice surely…Glasgow, Scotland, of course.
How do you guys find the will to keep fighting? I’ve lost Jaxson Dart for the season, and now probably Drake Maye as well, with a fractured ankle. How do you not just give up? – 6RingsMakaveli
Answer: Trust me 6Rings, there are times when all seems lost, and I want to throw in the towel…but as long as you are still mathematically in with a chance, you have got to keep on trucking. As a manager who also lost Dart earlier in the year (and had a Malik Nabers stack at the time), I too was on the edge…but some creative trading and a constant eagle-eyed gaze at the waiver wire has me smack bang in contention for back-to-back #FootClanTitles in my main League of Record. Keep your chin up and keep making moves…if all else fails, do your best to sabotage others’ seasons and let them join you in the pit of despair.
Hey Ballers! Important fantasy question here: if you were a Power Ranger, which color would you be and what creature would your Zord be? – CamNWat
Answer: Given my Celtic roots, the clear and obvious answer for me would be the Green Ranger, with my Zord taking the form of my country’s official national animal…the unicorn! No, I am not making that up…God bless Scotland and our somewhat unserious outlook on life.
That will do it for this week, FootClan – good luck for Week 11! Go find your fantasy unicorns!
